Resumo:
The intensive exploitation of natural resources and inadequate environmental planning are
factors that intensify environmental vulnerabilities, including the degradation of water
resources. This reality highlights the need for territorial planning that incorporates tools capable
of guiding conservation actions and integrated environmental and water management. In this
context, Geographic Information Systems (GIS), combined with multicriteria analysis methods
such as the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the application of fuzzy logic membership
functions, become essential to support decision-making, enabling more precise and well-
founded judgments. Given this scenario, the present study aimed to identify the environmental
and water-related vulnerabilities of the sub-watersheds in the municipality of Lorena, located
in the interior of the State of São Paulo, with the goal of supporting water resource conservation
and local environmental planning. Additionally, two methodologies were compared in this
identification process: overlay using arithmetic mean (referred to as the traditional method) and
the AHP method combined with fuzzy membership functions. The methodology was initially
based on a systematic literature review to select relevant environmental themes, which were
defined as slope, land use, pedology, rainfall, and permanent preservation areas (PPA).
Subsequently, for rainfall, two distinct climatic scenarios were analyzed: high rainfall intensity
and water scarcity. The sensitivity analysis confirmed the relevance of the selected themes, and
the water scarcity scenario was adopted as a reference for mapping. Thematic maps of the sub-
watersheds were created using Quantum GIS (QGIS) software, followed by reclassification of
the degrees of vulnerability (very low, low, moderate, high, and very high). In the traditional
method, a simple arithmetic mean was applied; in the AHP method, differentiated weights were
assigned based on expert evaluation. The results showed significant differences between the
methods. The arithmetic mean tended to homogenize the data, smoothing out environmental
variations. In contrast, the AHP method combined with fuzzy membership functions allowed
for a more detailed and accurate representation of territorial conditions, highlighting areas under
greater anthropogenic pressure and regions with preserved vegetation. It was concluded,
therefore, that the integration of fuzzy membership functions and multicriteria methods
represented an effective and improved methodological approach for analyzing environmental
and water vulnerability, especially in complex territories. The final product obtained has the
potential to support strategic actions for environmental management and planning, water
resource conservation, and the formulation of public policies in the municipality of Lorena.