Resumo:
Sanitary water heating in Brazil is a critical component of residential energy consumption, driven by cultural factors and associated with significant environmental impacts. Conventional analyses, focused solely on the use phase, are insufficient to capture the total environmental burdens, which include manufacturing, transportation, and final disposal. This dissertation assesses and compares the environmental viability of three residential water heating systems: an electric shower supplied by a photovoltaic panel, a flat-plate solar thermal collector, and a hybrid system composed of a heat pump and a photovoltaic-thermal (PV-T) panel. To this end, the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology is employed, accounting for the environmental impacts across all stages of each system, from raw-material extraction and equipment manufacturing to operation. The comparison adopts as a common basis the generation of 1 kWh of useful energy for water heating over a 20-year period, crediting each system for the conventional energy it replaces: the grid electricity displaced directly by the photovoltaic system and, in the thermal systems, the replacement of the electric shower. The inventory of each system was compiled from a literature review and experimental data and then modeled in the SimaPro software with the support of the Ecoinvent database. The study considers five Brazilian locations (Boa Vista, Natal, Cuiabá, Belo Horizonte, and Porto Alegre) in order to evaluate the influence of different climatic profiles and regional electricity grids. Results show that, considering only the manufacturing and operation footprint (gross perspective), the solar collector achieves the lowest impact across all cities; in Belo Horizonte, its global warming footprint is approximately 76% lower than that of PV and 83% lower than the hybrid's. When the avoided conventional energy is credited (net perspective), the ranking reverses: the hybrid and collector deliver approximately 29% and 24% more climate benefit per kWh than PV, respectively; PV is the only system to present a net environmental burden in metal-related categories, such as terrestrial ecotoxicity and mineral resource scarcity, as the benefit of displacing grid electricity does not offset its manufacturing footprint. Location strongly influences outcomes through the environmental profile of the regional electricity grid: the net climate benefit provided by the collector in Natal, where the grid is the most carbon-intensive, is approximately 2.9 times higher than in Porto Alegre. The solar collector is the most environmentally robust option due to the simplicity of its components, while the hybrid system offers the greatest net environmental benefit in regions where the displaced electricity is more carbon-intensive.